Physics Help Forum Refractive index of glass block

 Waves and Sound Waves and Sound Physics Help Forum

 Jan 25th 2016, 03:40 AM #1 Member   Join Date: Nov 2015 Posts: 38 Refractive index of glass block A student wants to find the refractive index of a rectangular block of glass. He draws around the block and marks the position of a ray of light that travels through the block. With the block removed, the student can draw in a normal line and then measure the angle of incidence and the angle of refraction. The student repeats this process for different angles of incidence. His measurements are shown in the table. Angle of incidence Angle of refraction 10° ............................... 6.5° 20° .................................. 13° 30° ...................................20° 40° ................................. 25° 50° ....................................32° 60° ..................................35° Snells law Refractive index = (sin i / sin r) What was the independent variable in this investigation? What was the dependent variable? Independent variable is the angle of incidence (because it is the one that can be varied). Dependent variable is the angle of refraction (because it is dependent on the angle of incidence). Have I got the independent and dependent variables mixed up? I'm concerned because I read somewhere that : x-axis = independent variable y-axis = dependent variable. But later in the question in the book it says: Draw a graph of sin i (y-axis) against sin r (x-axis). __________________ "Heat is the kinetic energy of the individual atoms or molecules"; MBW 2015
Jan 25th 2016, 06:08 AM   #2
Physics Team

Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Morristown, NJ USA
Posts: 2,336
 Originally Posted by Hero AWhat was the independent variable in this investigation? What was the dependent variable? Independent variable is the angle of incidence (because it is the one that can be varied). Dependent variable is the angle of refraction (because it is dependent on the angle of incidence). Have I got the independent and dependent variables mixed up?

 Originally Posted by Hero I'm concerned because I read somewhere that : x-axis = independent variable y-axis = dependent variable.
Yes, that is usually how graphs are drawn (but not always).

 Originally Posted by Hero But later in the question in the book it says: Draw a graph of sin i (y-axis) against sin r (x-axis).
I think it asks you to do this because Snell's Law is equal to sin i/sin r, and so drawing the graph this way will result in a best-fit straight line whose slope is equal to the index of refraction.

 Jan 26th 2016, 12:09 PM #3 Member   Join Date: Nov 2015 Posts: 38 Independent variable is the angle of incidence ...... so this is usually the x-axis Dependent variable is the angle of refraction ..... so this is usually the y-axis But in this question I've been asked to draw angle of incidence as the y-axis and angle of refraction as x-axis. Is just an ODD case where the rule does not apply? If I didn't know what the independent variable and dependent variable for this question ..... then I could be clever and notice (further along in the question) that I've been asked to "draw a graph of sin i (y-axis) against sin r (x-axis)" ..... then I could simply (incorrectly) assume that angle of incidence must be the dependent variable because this is the y-axis and make the same mistake for the independent variable. I WOULD GET THE ANSWER WRONG __________________ "Heat is the kinetic energy of the individual atoms or molecules"; MBW 2015 Last edited by Hero; Jan 26th 2016 at 12:11 PM.
 Jan 26th 2016, 12:37 PM #4 Physics Team     Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Morristown, NJ USA Posts: 2,336 Yes, it's odd, and yes, it's good that you are smart enough to know they have asked you to make a plot that swaps the usual convention of independent and dependent axes. You asked "why" they are making you do this, and I gave a reasonable explanation - does it make sense to you?
 Jan 26th 2016, 01:50 PM #5 Member   Join Date: Nov 2015 Posts: 38 Yes thanks I understood your explaination. I thought the rule that x-axis = independent variable and y-axis = dependent variable was fixed in stone. So now I know its a general rule and if I'm stuck on what is the independent variable and dependent variable in a particular experiment is ..... I can look at the graph and take a punt that the x-axis is the independent. Now i know it will only be a punt and its better to know the proper answer __________________ "Heat is the kinetic energy of the individual atoms or molecules"; MBW 2015 Last edited by Hero; Jan 26th 2016 at 01:54 PM.
 Jan 27th 2016, 05:43 AM #6 Senior Member     Join Date: Apr 2008 Location: Bedford, England Posts: 668 A picture is worth 1000 words A graph is just a tool to help you visualise the relationship between to parameters. Differently scaled axes are often used when the relationship between the parameters is not a simple linear relationship (the graph is not a simple straight line). In the olden days (when I were a lad) we had packs of special graph paper where one (or sometimes both) axis would be logarithmic (for example). I suggest you try plotting the data both ways (if you have Excel then plotting two graphs will be barely more time consuming than plotting one). The benefits of the different axes should then become evident. Note that one set of axes may be better for showing one feature of the data while a different set of axes might highlight another feature of the data. __________________ You have GOT to Laugh !

 Tags block, glass, index, refractive

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

,

# what is the refractive index of rectangular glass block

Click on a term to search for related topics.
 Thread Tools Display Modes Linear Mode

 Similar Physics Forum Discussions Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post vahab Advanced Optics 0 Apr 12th 2013 07:09 AM tariq_h_tauheed Light and Optics 1 Oct 18th 2009 12:39 AM ATH500 Light and Optics 3 Apr 2nd 2009 11:13 PM zaw lin Light and Optics 2 Dec 14th 2008 08:18 AM TwistedOne151 Thermodynamics and Fluid Mechanics 1 May 3rd 2008 03:07 AM