User Name Remember Me? Password

 Thermodynamics and Fluid Mechanics Thermodynamics and Fluid Mechanics Physics Help Forum Jan 21st 2015, 05:37 AM #1 Junior Member   Join Date: Jan 2015 Posts: 5 Fluid mechanics question Guys,I am a new member.I am a bit confused about this problem A simplified schematic of the rain drainage system for a barn is shown in the figure (attached). Rain falling on the slanted roof runs off into gutters around the roof edge; it then drains through several downspouts (only one is shown) into a main drainage pipe M below the basement, which carries the water to an even larger pipe. A floor drain in the basement is also connected to drainage pipe M. The question arises, if such design can cope with heavy storm events such as recently experienced in Australia. Suppose the following apply: 1. the downspouts have height h1 = 11 m 2. the floor drain has height h2 = 1.2 m 3. pipe M has radius 3.0 cm, 4. the barn has a width w = 30 m and a length L = 60 m, 5. all the water striking the roof goes through pipe M , 6. the initial water speed in a downspout is negligible, 7. the wind speed is negligible (the rain falls vertically). (a) By applying Bernoullis principle, determine the speed of water in pipe M, when the basement floor is on the verge of being flooded. (b) Calculate using the continuity equation at what rainfall rate, in centimeters per hour, such flooding will occur? An attempt at the solution:- I have made too many assumptions My assumptions:- 1) Imagine a rectangle and imagine pulling it from its center,raising a pyramid.I assume the roof to be of this pyramidal shape so that,the exposed surface area of this pyramid is same as that of the base.(This is not the case with all pyramids) 2) Pressure inside the house is the same as the atmospheric pressure. 3) Water collected in the pipe joining the floor drainage and the pipe M is stagnant(at rest) Solution: Let the point in M directly below the floor drainage be called point 1),the point where a downspout begins as point 3) and the point at the floor drainage as point 2). Consider a y axis such that y1=0,y2=h2,y3=h1 Between 1) and 2) P1=P2 + Rg(y2-y1) (water is at rest) P1= Pa + Rgh2 Since 3) is exposed to the atmosphere,P3=Pa Therefore,P1-P3=Rgh2 Applying Bernoulli's equation between 1) and 3):- P1+0.5R(v1^2)+Rgy1=P3+0.5R(v3^2)+Rgy3 Therefore, P1-P3=Rgh1-0.5R(v1^2) P1-P3=Rgh2 Therefore, Rgh2=Rgh1-0.5R(v1^2) This gives v1=13.85929291m/s Volume flow rate=A1v1=0.039186227 Continuity:- Volume flow rate=Rainfall volume rate rate Now,a point on the roof receives a volume (vdt).da in a time dt where v=speed of rain and da=area of point.Therefore,volume rate=vda Integrating,flow rate=lbv where l and b anre length and breadth. lbv=A1v1 Solving the above would give v=2.177 x (10^-5) m/s=7.84 cm/h Please tell me if I am correct or not    Jan 21st 2015, 09:55 AM #2 Senior Member   Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: NC Posts: 418 Barn Flood Prevention... Hello SOP, I took a look at this. I'm not sure the pipe diameters are the same. I'll attach what I have you can see what you think. Also might I suggest that you spend no more of your precious life taking time to write science numbers such as -> A1v1 = 0.0391867227 cc/s. No device exists in any laboratory (here or Russia) that can measure a volume rate to the nearest 0.0000000001 cc/s. A1v1 = 0.039 cc/s is enough already. Also, my hydrostatics work is here: http://www.thermospokenhere.com/tsh/...d=Ideal Fluids Good luck with your studies. TSH for PHF   Jan 21st 2015, 10:04 AM #3 Junior Member   Join Date: Jan 2015 Posts: 5 Hi Thermo thanks for the quick reply. I didn't know the rules so I typed out the full calculator display lol. Shall keep it in mind. The radius of M is given as 3 cm What do you think about my assumption about the area?   Jan 21st 2015, 10:07 AM #4 Junior Member   Join Date: Jan 2015 Posts: 5 I have assumed that water is at rest between 1 and 2. We don't need to consider the radius of the downspouts because we have to consider the volume received by the roof. The other thing is that we don't know the number of downspouts so no point talking about its cross sectional area Last edited by StudentOfPhysics; Jan 21st 2015 at 10:11 AM.   Jan 21st 2015, 12:57 PM #5 Senior Member   Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: NC Posts: 418 Hi SOP... Hello again, I don't know what the configuration is. I hate to fool around guessing. It must be there are "many" (/) downpipes. Each leads to its own "M." The fact of the standpipe (1) - (2) must mean the water downward (through a single one) enters with very small velocity. This way Vm can be calculated. (see my energy equation with V3 = 0 ~ very small but not 0). Now about the area. Knowing the flow through "M" is not enough to determine the rate of rain. Good Luck TSH for PHF   Jan 21st 2015, 09:53 PM #6 Junior Member   Join Date: Jan 2015 Posts: 5 Hi thermo I don't think that you can apply Bernoulli's equation between 1 and 2 because BE can only be applied along a streamline and there is no streamline that goes from M to the floor drainage and back to M because a streamline cannot turn within a pipe as we have assumed that all the fluid elements within a cross section have the same velocity which is not possible if there 2 opposite streamlines within a cross section. Now, each fluid element travelling in M comes from the roof,assuming no drainage from the house itself. Therefore the rate of volume of rainwater being received on the roof is the same as the volume flow rate through M. Therefore Bernoulli's equation can be applied for a fluid element's journey from the roof to the pipe M. Steady flow is assumed.   Jan 22nd 2015, 09:29 AM #7 Senior Member   Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: NC Posts: 418 Momentum Equation Properties (1) are related to (2) by the momentum equation (hydrostatic equation, as some would say). http://www.thermospokenhere.com/wp/0...hydro_eqn.html I didn't use Bernouilli. In fact I don't use Bernouilli. I prefer the energy equation for a flow (Bernouilli is part of the energy equation).. The problem is poorly posed. There must be many more than 1 "M-type" pathway. All that water through on D=6cm pipe? What text is this? Good Luck... SOP TSH for PHF  Tags fluid, mechanics, question ,

,

,

,

# water velocity of slanted roof

Click on a term to search for related topics.
 Thread Tools Show Printable Version Email this Page Display Modes Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode Similar Physics Forum Discussions Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post charlielife Thermodynamics and Fluid Mechanics 3 Jun 13th 2014 05:37 AM obas21 Thermodynamics and Fluid Mechanics 10 Jun 10th 2014 10:53 PM roshanhero Advanced Mechanics 0 Jan 27th 2011 01:07 PM BearN Advanced Waves and Sound 0 Nov 23rd 2009 01:54 PM Apprentice123 Advanced Mechanics 1 Sep 29th 2009 06:02 PM