Apr 15th 2017, 03:28 PM
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: On the dance floor, baby!
Originally Posted by kiwiheretic
Been watching some youtube videos about the derivation of the PDE wave equation Uxx = c^2*Utt
It seems to me they made a lot of unrealistic assumptions when deriving it, namely:
- Vibration amplitudes are small
- The tension in the wave is the same everywhere
- Vertical displacement only
Given that a lot of physics (eg: QM, Maxwell's equations, etc) is built around Uxx = c^2*Utt being law doesn't this make all the conclusions a bit dodgy?
You are absolutely right. The wave equation (which normally does a fine job) is full of variety of assumptions. Most of Physics depends on a number of unnatural assumptions, three of which you have already mentioned. The problem is that if we write a more realistic equation it is harder to solve. Replace too many assumptions for more realism and you will wind up with an unsolvable problem. Here's
a "down and dirty" look at the non-linear wave equation.
I'm a "something shiny" kind of...Oh look! Something shiny!
See the forum rules here