Physics Help Forum

Physics Help Forum (
-   Periodic and Circular Motion (
-   -   Kepler's Laws vs Energy (

haksaw22 Oct 30th 2016 03:00 PM

Kepler's Laws vs Energy
Screenshot by Lightshot

The question is in the link above.
I have already looked at unofficial markscheme for this, and it appears to have used vr=v'r' as a form of kepplers law of equal areas, which results in C being circled.
I used a different method, to get B, where I equated the PE and KE to get v^2 = k/r, and then solved for k. Then I plugged it back in with the new radius to get a new velocity of about 30. I have no clue whether or not my method holds, nor why, so it'd be nice to get some clarification on this.

Btw im new here, apologies if this isnt where it should be

ChipB Oct 30th 2016 04:08 PM

Yes, the answer to the question as written is "about" 30 - actually 31.6Km/s.

I'm wondering if there isn't a typo in tjhe question - if the radius of the orbit at maximum was 10 x 10^11Km instead of 10 x 10^10Km, there would be a nice round number for the answer.

haksaw22 Oct 30th 2016 04:39 PM

Thanks for the confirmation! I'm pretty sure there isn't a typo, which is weird given that its a non calc paper. Do you know why the law of equal areas method they've used doesn't work?

ChipB Oct 30th 2016 09:12 PM

Sorry, but I realize I made a mistake in my earlier post. Using Kepler's Law of equal area in equal time does indeed yield an answer of (c), which is 20 Km/s. My error (and I think yours too) was in mistakenly using an equation that works for circular orbits, but this problem is about an elliptical orbit. I used a formula that equates force of gravity to mass times centripetal acceleration of the comet, which is valid for a circular orbit:

GMm/r^2 = m v^2/r

This yields v^2r = constant, but ignores the fact that at perigee and apogee the comet in an elliptical orbit has radial as well as centripetal acceleration, so gives the wrong answer.

Sorry for any confusion on this.

haksaw22 Oct 31st 2016 03:20 AM

No problem, thanks again! Makes more sense now, subtleties always catch me out.

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 11:07 PM.

Copyright © 2016 Physics Help Forum. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 2008-2012 Physics Help Forum. All rights reserved.