Physics Help Forum Somebody solve this mystery for me.

 Kinematics and Dynamics Kinematics and Dynamics Physics Help Forum

 Feb 27th 2018, 06:15 AM #1 Senior Member     Join Date: Feb 2017 Posts: 203 Somebody solve this mystery for me. As I was explaining Newtons First Law. I said " An object will remain at rest or in uniform motion in a straight line unless acted upon by an external force." Dan said "What if a person is inside the car and handbrakes aren't applied and he pushes the car from the inside, the force is internal since he is inside the car." My argument is that it is still an external force. How? Let me make it easier. Tyre generates friction in three major ways adhesion, deformation and wear. Adhesion: Adhesion is the property of tyre that causes it to stick to other material. Adhesion generally thought to be the result of momentarily molecular bonding between two surface. Adhesion friction is the major contributor in tyre traction. Tyre in contact with a smooth surface generates friction force mainly by adhesion. Deformation and wear friction has less contribution in tyre traction on smooth surface. So it could mean that Adhesion is not all that great in this case or happens later on after the car moves a certain distance. Deformation and wear friction are ruled out. So the car isnt moving because the car is pushed forward by Dan but because the friction is reduced to zero at the point. But even in case of a ball when you slide it horizontally on a frictionless surface you are exerting a force initially then it moves horizontally forever due to no friction Which makes us find out whether the internal force of Dan is unbalanced. Last edited by avito009; Feb 27th 2018 at 06:23 AM.
 Feb 27th 2018, 06:46 AM #2 Senior Member   Join Date: Apr 2015 Location: Somerset, England Posts: 987 There is nothing to find out. All internal forces are balanced, unless the object is changing shape, which rigid bodies don't, by definition. Think about Dan's man. (Gosh I'm a poet that don't know it) He pushes with his hands and arms onto the dash. But unless he also pushes back onto the seat with his back or feet or something with a force that is equal in magnitude, but opposite in direction, he will simply move himself within the vehicle. I will leave you to put this in formal terms, perhaps using N1,N2 and N3. A further twist, what is the situation if the man is standing on the ground and leans into the car to push on the dash? topsquark likes this.
 Feb 27th 2018, 08:29 AM #3 Senior Member     Join Date: Feb 2017 Posts: 203 Simplification. Let us simplify this way Dan's man is pushed towards the seat as he exerts force on the dashboard. So here: The force of the seat pushing on him = force of this man on the dashboard + force required to move the car forward. Which explains the internal forces to be equal. Is this correct?
Feb 27th 2018, 09:57 AM   #4
Senior Member

Join Date: Apr 2015
Location: Somerset, England
Posts: 987
 Originally Posted by avito009 Let us simplify this way Dan's man is pushed towards the seat as he exerts force on the dashboard. So here: The force of the seat pushing on him = force of this man on the dashboard + force required to move the car forward. Which explains the internal forces to be equal. Is this correct?
Well that's progress.

However you have not expressed it formally, as I requested.

Here is a start.

By Newton's third law (N3) the dash pushes back on Dan's man with equal but opposite force to the push the man exerts on the dash.

You need to employ two of Newton's laws to complete this.

It may sound stuffy and pedantic but this chain of reasoning leads to important conclusions in every part of statics and dynamics, including rotational dynamics.

And how about my second question?

Thinking about these helps you learn.

 Feb 27th 2018, 10:14 PM #5 Senior Member     Join Date: Feb 2017 Posts: 203 Newtons Laws. Studiot, you have explained the third law of newton working here. Now let me put up the first and second law of newton here. Newtons First Law: The car moves ahead as Dan's man pushes on the dashboard. Here there is an external force which is the force of Gravity. You see if the road was perfectly smooth the car would have not moved on its own. But there must be a slight slope on the earth where the car stands. Similar to a ball on an inclined plane. On the inclined plane there is a force of gravity. So here gravity is the external force. Due to the net external force of gravity and reduced friction the car moves ahead. Newtons Second Law: F= ma. There is force only when there is acceleration. The car is initially accelerated from zero speed to say one unit of speed. Which is acceleration of 1 unit. The car moves due to this acceleration. Again read what I said in other posts. F=ma works as a formula for gravity. Lets say mass of the car is 1 kg. So force due to gravity = 1 x 1 = 1. So we are right that it is the force of gravity due to which the car moves. Newtons Third Law: You exert a force on the dashboard and the car moves a bit ahead. Equal this with the force pushing on you by the stationary seat. There is an equal and opposite force acting. Which means the force is balanced. According to N3 there is a balanced force. But according to N1 and N2 force of gravity is unbalanced from the force of friction. But gravity is an external force. Conclusion: Internal forces on the car are balanced and external forces namely gravity is unbalanced.
 Feb 27th 2018, 10:18 PM #6 Senior Member     Join Date: Feb 2017 Posts: 203 Gravity as External Force. Here "Car" is the system so gravity is an external force. But if Car-Earth system is taken then gravity is an internal force. This is because the mechanical energy is conserved in the Car-Earth system.
 Apr 28th 2018, 01:01 AM #8 Senior Member     Join Date: Feb 2017 Posts: 203 Final Answer. Well the answer is really simple if you see. When a person applies a force on the dashboard and the car moves forward he is applying an external force. Take for example a baseball bat hitting a ball. Here there is an external force on the ball by the baseball bat. So in our example we can say that the hand of the person inside the car is the baseball bat and the ball is the dashboard. So answer is simple it is an external force applied on the car which moves it forward. So the person who asked me the question stating that it was an internal force since the driver was in the car was wrong. Internal forces are: The gravity forces, magnetic force, electrical force, and spring force. Since none of these are involved in our question it proves that the force applied is external.
Apr 28th 2018, 09:47 AM   #9

Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: On the dance floor, baby!
Posts: 2,438
 Originally Posted by avito009 Well the answer is really simple if you see. When a person applies a force on the dashboard and the car moves forward he is applying an external force. Take for example a baseball bat hitting a ball. Here there is an external force on the ball by the baseball bat. So in our example we can say that the hand of the person inside the car is the baseball bat and the ball is the dashboard. So answer is simple it is an external force applied on the car which moves it forward. So the person who asked me the question stating that it was an internal force since the driver was in the car was wrong. Internal forces are: The gravity forces, magnetic force, electrical force, and spring force. Since none of these are involved in our question it proves that the force applied is external.
However I was stating that no external forces act on the car. I should have mentioned gravity but the car does not move vertically either so it cancels out and has no effect on the car.

If the car is moving then we have to be doing work on it. Work, in it's most general definition, is defined as a change in one form of energy to another. In this case we have chemical energy (from ATP or some other biological process) being converted to kinetic energy. So there is an imbalance.

If it helps I was never considering a constant force on the car. It has to be done by "lunges" or some other gross body movement of Dan's man (I like that), not a steady push on the dashboard.

-Dan
__________________
Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup.

See the forum rules here.

 May 1st 2018, 02:07 PM #10 Banned   Join Date: Apr 2018 Posts: 92 Yes I agree and believe this is an extremely important fact that is being described but in every theory there is also a fundamental part that does not always seem real which I hope you will discuss more completely but In all that is being said it is extremely inspiring.

 Tags mystery, solve

 Thread Tools Display Modes Linear Mode

 Similar Physics Forum Discussions Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post JustKiddingImNotAPhD Theoretical Physics 1 Jan 9th 2017 06:20 AM Stephie Electricity and Magnetism 0 Mar 1st 2014 07:04 AM Tyson Thermodynamics and Fluid Mechanics 0 Jan 17th 2013 08:18 PM nahama Equilibrium and Elasticity 4 Jul 11th 2010 07:58 AM r.samanta Atomic and Solid State Physics 4 Nov 10th 2009 03:17 AM