Physics Help Forum Problems with pulleys

Dec 5th 2012, 09:51 AM   #1
Junior Member

Join Date: Dec 2012
Location: Seattle, WA
Posts: 4
Problems with pulleys

My brother has a 4'x16' model train layout in his garage. He has constructed a counter-balanced pulley system to raise the layout to the ceiling. However, something is not right--it simply doesn't work.

I'll upload a 3D PDF of the system, in the hopes that all those people with WAY more understanding of the physics behind this stuff can give us some ideas as to where we're going wrong.

Addl info: We've verified that the cables circle the pulleys in the directions shown in the PDF. The large pulleys are approx. 6" diameter; the small pulleys are approx. 1.5" diameter.

Attached Files
 Pulleys.pdf (171.3 KB, 7 views)

 Dec 5th 2012, 10:07 AM #2 Physics Team     Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Morristown, NJ USA Posts: 2,352 Please clarify some things. I'm assuming that the pulley system shown is attached to the ceiling, the "40's" on the drawing represent the weight of the train set, and the "120" is a counter-balance weight - correct? This should work if all the pulleys are equal diameter, but you say they're not; I can't tell from the figure which pulleys are "large" and which are "small," so please clarify that. Finally, you say the system doesn't work - but in what way doesn't it work? Does the train set fall to the ground? Smash into the ceiling? Does it take more than 120 pounds to keep it steady?
 Dec 5th 2012, 12:00 PM #4 Physics Team     Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Morristown, NJ USA Posts: 2,352 It seems to me that this should work just fine. The size of the little green pulleys is immaterial. But since it doesn't work let me ask a few more questions: 1. Are you sure that the total weight of the train set (including the little pulleys) is 240#? 2. Are the large pulleys all firmly secured to the axles that they are mounted on? How so? 3. I know you said he verified that the ropes are oriented as shown in the figure, but just to be sure have him take a couple of photos and email them to you. The fact that he gets no movement makes me think that some of them may be reversed. I would suggest trying the system with a much lighter load to trouble shoot it. For example start with, say, a 5 pound load on just one of the little green pulleys and see if the system works (i.e. the pulleys turn and the load rises and falls as expected). Then put 5 pounds on a second little green pulley, etc, working up to all six having 5 pounds each. Verify that with 30 pounds spread over the 6 points it takes 15 pounds to raise it, as expected. Report back as to what he finds. Last edited by ChipB; Dec 5th 2012 at 12:13 PM.
 Dec 5th 2012, 12:50 PM #5 Junior Member   Join Date: Dec 2012 Location: Seattle, WA Posts: 4 I'll let you know what we find out. Thanks, again, for your help.
 Dec 5th 2012, 02:07 PM #6 Physics Team     Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: Morristown, NJ USA Posts: 2,352 Glad to help - I'm really interested to see what the problem is. One additional thought: there is a net force acting on the middle axle of about 120 pound to the side plus 80 pounds vertical - I wonder if perhaps the bearings at each end of the axle can't handle it, and so it's binding? Another reason to try it with a lighter load first.
 Dec 5th 2012, 02:18 PM #7 Junior Member   Join Date: Dec 2012 Location: Seattle, WA Posts: 4 I called my brother, and suggested he: - Detach all 6 of the support cables from the table. - Hang a 5# wt on ONE of the support cables - Put 5# in the counterweight and see if it works. I figure that, if it just happens that he's mistaken about one or more of the cables running the wrong way, this will uncover the error. Again, thanks, and I'll let you know what we find.

 Tags problems, pulleys

 Thread Tools Display Modes Linear Mode

 Similar Physics Forum Discussions Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post amey Kinematics and Dynamics 0 Nov 19th 2011 05:30 AM bradycat Kinematics and Dynamics 4 Mar 3rd 2011 05:19 AM bradycat Kinematics and Dynamics 1 Feb 15th 2011 06:37 AM angelfrmhvn Advanced Mechanics 1 Feb 19th 2009 03:49 PM collegestudent321 Kinematics and Dynamics 1 Feb 5th 2009 06:39 PM